Skip to main content

Stay at home mothers Vs Working mothers- Bloggers' marathon entry


Stay at home Vs Working Moms

First of all, let me tweak the topic a bit; let me make it Stay at home moms and Working moms; let’s talk about the lives they lead, the challenges they face, the sacrifices they make and the rewards they take; for once let us NOT compare them.
Versus often written as vs. is a Latin word meaning 'against' or it may mean to have a comparison or a competition between two teams/parties.
Mothers do what they feel is best for their off-springs; whether they stay at home or work outside their homes, I would never wish to question their choices.
When I was younger, studying and working, I couldn’t ever imagine myself not working or staying at home, changing diapers, feeding the baby and worrying about the piles of laundry and what to cook next. I could not visualize it because I have been brought up in a family where everyone worked and earned. My father has always insisted that women be financially independent. He has helped distant relatives, people in our village, He would counsel the girls and their families to pursue professional courses and help them further, getting a job.
But here I am today, changing diapers, feeding, cooking and doing everything I thought I wouldn’t be doing. Such is life! Do I regret it? Hell no, I don’t regret it because I find being close to my baby rewarding, I think I am blessed to be able to be with him, to be able to give him the time I can; to hold him close while he is still little and can’t run away from me.
Every household, every family has their own circumstances, what works for me may not work for others and hence, all mothers choose what works best for them and their kids.

While a working mom would be overwhelmed and heartbroken while leaving a sleeping or crying baby home; a stay at home mom too has her own meltdown moments; when she would literally wish someone adopted her baby for an hour or two, well I sometimes do wish that. There are challenges that both have to face, while one has to dabble between work and home, the other has to live with the guilt of not being financially independent and monotony of everyday life.
Let us get united in motherhood,  let’s talk about the lives they lead, the challenges they face, the sacrifices they make and the rewards they take; for once let us NOT compare them.

What challenges do SAH mommies face?

·         The guilt of not being able to work outside home or not being able to earn tops the list of all the challenges.
·         SAHMs are often taken for granted at home, feel unappreciated by their very own family members.
·         Being with the child all the time is gratifying, but one does need a break; which is difficult for a SAHM to come by (Ask me, pheww)
·         Being highly qualified and working until you had a baby, suddenly makes it difficult to assimilate the fact that you are not working, mentally it does get taxing.
·         Seeing your colleagues, batchmates climb up their career ladder may also give a lot of complex to many SAH moms.
·         Finding a job after you have been a SAHM for long again gets difficult.
I still remember my mother-in-law often lament the fact that everyone in the house earned, except her. In reality, she was the one who had put everything together so beautifully and tirelessly year after year.

What challenges do Working mommies face?

·         With most families going the nuclear way, it is becoming difficult for a working woman to leave the child home, which earlier wouldn’t have been difficult with grandparents looking after the kids.
·         Working mothers have difficulty balancing both home and work. In patriarchal society like ours, the onus to manage the house is on a woman; though times are changing, but it will still take a while before men take equal responsibilities in daily household chores.
·         Leaving behind few months old baby; expressing milk or making arrangements for baby to be fed in the absence is not an easy task.
·         Being a working mother is a perpetual struggle with PTMs and boardroom meetings.
·         It is still going to take a while for that glass ceiling to break for our women in the working world.
·         Finding reliable day-care or help is again a big issue in our country where house-helps fall under unorganised sector and only few day-cares are reliable.

According to a study conducted by Timesjobs this year (2017), 70% of working-women in India rated “flexibility” at their workplaces as Poor. This clearly shows why women tend to quit their jobs once they have babies.

I would also like to talk about the society, how it perceives a working woman; not too long back, there was an incident where a 10mo baby was beaten up by a caretaker at a popular Navi-Mumbai day care. Instead of questioning the Day-care authorities and empathising with the parents, the mother was talked off (on social media and otherwise) as careless and ambitious; well, was she really careless, I don’t think so, and if she was being questioned, why not the father, are parents not equally responsible for their babies. Women are often judged whether they choose to stay at home or pursue their career aspirations; and more often than not, it is the other woman who judges another woman’s choice.
The only advice I have for all my fellow mommies is to seek help whenever they need; we may multi-task and be supermoms, but we do have our own limitations; let us accept the reality and take each day as it comes. For all my SAHM mommies, ours is the time when we have plethora of activities and prospects. Pursue your hobbies, travel if you can, indulge in activities that will enrich you and your child together and use this time, if you can, for honing your professional skills; so that it is easier for you to find a job,(if you wish to) later in life.
There is no one perfect way to be a good mother. Each mother has different challenges, different skills and abilities, and certainly different children. The choice is different and unique for each mother and each family -Elder M. Russell Ballard

Please share your views on pros and cons of being a SAHM and a Working mom.








Comments

  1. Both are superb of their own way. You cant give preference to only one type. Both managing their home, family and specially kids with their special skills. Moms are always best wheather working or stay at home.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Both are superb of their own way. You cant give preference to only one type. Both managing their home, family and specially kids with their special skills. Moms are always best wheather working or stay at home.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very true Minakshi. Life would be so much better if people didn't judge one another's choice.

      Delete
  3. Finding a job after taking a break is difficult. This is especially high in India. Our country has a lot of unnecessary stigmas!

    ReplyDelete
  4. this article is just BANG ON! i hve been prt of both worlds and constantly dwindled between them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thank you :) would love to read your journey transitioning between both the worlds.

      Delete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have been a super workaholic and never thought I'd want to be home.. But here I am.. But now that my kids are independent and I'm looking to get back to the grind, the reactions that I get from people including women about my break are appalling... Our society is so insensitive and judgmental

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. true Sabeeka, holds true for many of us. I hope things change for better.

      Delete
  7. I have grown up observing both type of moms and still couldn't figure it out how they manage it! Hats off to both! I do not even know if I can do that! πŸ™ˆ (Note: not a mommy! 😁)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I loved your comment. yes, I still wonder how my mom managed everything, but they just do. I am a new mom n managing somehow.

      Delete
  8. Both are no less a mother, it is choice that is required by the society or personally - depends from person to person! I am a stay at home mom, so the challenges are not much, but then again - everyone has their own share of goods and bads - being a mom is awesome! irrespective of being a SAH or working!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Its tough , whatever be the choice. There is dilemma and troubles. There are some positives and some negatives. "While a working mom would be overwhelmed and heartbroken while leaving a sleeping or crying baby home; a stay at home mom too has her own meltdown moments; when she would literally wish someone adopted her baby for an hour or two."- you have clearly explained the confusion faced by moms in these lines. Good post.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Yay! Women Power 🎩 Hats off. Being a women is almost equal to being an all rounder.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Comparison would be wrong.. I think both are wonderful on their on ways :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. that is what my blogpost is all about :)

      Delete
  12. This is one debate which I believe have been going on for ages now. I think both of them have their own challenges and they beautifully take care of their responsibilities. They are in true sense super women.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Absolutely loved every word!! it's all about prioritizing

    ReplyDelete
  14. I Personally never like to judge working moms or stay at home moms. I have been both. But, I have seen people comparing each other. Which is not correct. I think both the moms are just momwhen it comes to take care of their children :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, yes, people judge, compare do everything else but empathise!

      Delete
  15. Both moms are equally good and dedicated towards their family... I am glad to live both the lives

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. true. there shouldn't be any comparing or judging

      Delete
  16. I was a working woman for 10 yrs and then he came into my life, the precious bundle of joy... Your writing just translated my life and feelings into your words😍

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks a lot :) only mommies understand the real struggle

      Delete
  17. Superb Article. I think both moms are superwoman in their own way. Sometime I feel to quit my job because of my baby. But then realize that some how my job is my identity.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thank you papri, yes, each mom has her own challenges to deal with.

      Delete
  18. Stay at home moms and Working moms both are doing their best. the challenges are every where. I am a mom who stay at home and simultaneously maintain a blog for own identity. I believe that I am a woman first and thn mother. So I salute both.

    ReplyDelete
  19. It is entirely a woman's choice to decide whether she wants to stay at home or work.. I hope society stops judging mothers for that

    ReplyDelete
  20. It is Woman's choice to be a housewife or a working woman. I have seen both in my family so i love both the roles.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Musical Bonding - A Playful and Innovative Music Class for Parent & Child

If you have followed my blog-series on music, you would already know what I am talking about.

Musical bonding holds a very special place for us and we have found our emotional connect to it; so, my series wouldn't be complete without a dedicated post on it.

To get a better understanding of this parent -child programme for all my readers, I spoke to Aditi Shah, founder of Musical Bonding and here is what she has to say about one of her babies- "MB"!! 
  How did you come up with a programme that is so unique to Indian market?

Musical Bonding did not happen as a planned programme for the Indian market. The music provided by The Music Class allowed us (my husband and me) to have lots of fun with our two kids, singing, dancing and learning. Musical Bonding started as a simple attempt to make some friends in a new country and for the benefit of my own kids.
  Why Music, what does music mean to you?

I have background in Indian classical music and know that it is not the kind of musi…

from babyhood to Toddlerhood "the first birthday"

Hello ppl! 
 As we were getting close to 1 year, we knew we had to thank many friends and relatives who had called on, brought gifts and showed much love for baby A.
India is mostly about a lot of celebration and feasting. We wanted to have a big birthday function to celebrate  the 1 year mark and thank one and all.

My planning had started months before the birthday. I wanted a simple, yet memorable and enthralling experience esp. for kids; also off late I have been thinking about our carbon footprints and how we can reduce waste, so my thoughts and ideas revolved around a sustainable and eco-friendly celebration.
 When I thought of a grand celebration, I immediately got an image of grand waste being created by way of balloons, wrapping papers, plastic, flex, plastic bottles etc. and it left me thinking if I can make an attempt to minimise it to best possible  extent. So I was set for a "no balloon/flex/plastic decor" party. Instead of chalkboard and flex banners, I got a…

Review- Pantene Oil Replacement

Gone are the hostel days when I used to sit with my friends for long head massage/ oiling sessions along with lots of gossip.

I now end up running behind a toddler with my hair crazily tied up in a messy bun. Also now i don't  really like oiling my hair, may be because i don't have time for it and also because washing hair after oiling needs extra efforts.

So, I rarely use oil, thankfully I am blessed with good hair, but still one needs to take some bit of care. With approaching winter and hair getting dry I was wondering which oil to buy, and just then I came across this Oil replacement cream. What a wonderful product for people who can't stand oil or who have no time or luxury to get their hair oiled.

 The New Pantene Oil Replacement has Pro-V and goodness of oils; giving you two times stronger hair.

Why I liked this product- when I first used it, I felt my hair a little sticky, but I realised I had used a larger quantity. The stickiness though went away in sometime. T…